Meeting Tools Lab

Some links are affiliate links. They never change a result. How we make money

Fireflies vs Otter: which AI note taker is more accurate?

Tested · Last updated · By Miglė

In our test Otter wrote the more accurate transcripts (12.9% word errors against Fireflies' 14.7% on a 17-minute meeting, 6.6% against 10.3% on a non-native English speaker), but Fireflies wrote the more complete summaries: 11 of 13 decisions and action items on a four-person meeting against Otter's 8, and 5 of 8 against 2 on the accented recording. Fireflies' free plan ran out after one meeting; Otter's gives 300 minutes a month.

Fireflies vs Otter at a glance

Tested on 15 November 2026, both on free plans, on the same two recordings in the same call. Part of our test of five AI note takers.

Fireflies Otter
Word error rate, non-native speaker (2.5 min) 10.3% 6.6%
Word error rate, 4-person meeting (17 min) 14.7% 12.9%
Summary items caught, meeting (of 13) 11 8
Summary items caught, non-native recording (of 8) 5 2
Action items with owners yes no owners; none on the second recording
Names wrong in the summary “Russell”, “Reza”, “Java” none in the summary
Free plan in practice transcript hidden after our first meeting; a new free account showed the next one in full 300 minutes a month, 30 per conversation
Cheapest paid plan (15 Nov 2026) Pro, $10 per seat per month billed annually Pro, $8.33 per user per month billed annually

Lower word error rate is better: 10% means roughly one word in ten was wrong, missing or invented.

Which is more accurate: Fireflies or Otter?

Otter, in both recordings. On the 2.5-minute recording of a Lithuanian speaker of English, Otter got 6.6% of words wrong and Fireflies 10.3%: 18 errors against 28 in 272 words. Fireflies added two words that were never said at the start (“sa foreign”) and turned “the bugs” into “the box”. Both struggled with the colleagues’ names (Rasa became “Rosa” in Otter).

On the 17-minute four-person meeting Otter had the lowest word error rate of all five tools we tested, 12.9%; Fireflies had 14.7%, fourth of five. Most of Fireflies’ errors were words it left out (218 against Otter’s 159). On the test day Fireflies’ free plan had used its quota on the first recording and hid this transcript after about 2.5 minutes (“0 free meetings left”), so we played the same recording to Fireflies again on a new free account on 16 November, same setup, and scored that transcript.

Which writes better summaries?

Fireflies, clearly. Before the test we listed the decisions and action items in each recording and counted how many each summary contained.

  • Four-person meeting: Fireflies caught 11 of 13, Otter 8. Fireflies listed action items per person (“Rose Lindgren: Prepare next meeting agenda; Type kickoff meeting minutes”). Otter’s action items had no names and read like headings (“Clarify remote control scope”, “Condense next meeting tasks”), and it left out that Rose was the project manager and would send the minutes.
  • Non-native recording: Fireflies caught 5 of 8, Otter 2. Otter’s overview was accurate (release moved to 1 March, 42 open bugs, 11 critical) but its action items list was empty, so nobody was assigned anything.

The catch with Fireflies is what it gets wrong. On the accented recording its summary gave the support task to “Reza” and the design task to “Java”, and it wrote “Initial release move: March 21” when the release moved from 15 February to 1 March (its own recap a few lines later says March 1). On the meeting, both tools wrote a profit aim of “50 million” euro; the speaker says fifteen million (we listened to check at 7:40), so neither summary gets that item.

So: Fireflies tells you more of who does what, and you should check the names and dates before you send it on. Otter’s summary is shorter and safer, but you will write the action items yourself.

Free plans and pricing

Prices from each vendor’s own pricing page on 15 November 2026.

Fireflies Otter
Free plan, from the pricing page Limited AI summaries and storage 300 minutes a month, 30 minutes per conversation, 3 lifetime file imports
Free plan in our test Summary of the second meeting was kept; its transcript was hidden after about 2.5 minutes. A new free account showed the full transcript Both recordings transcribed and summarised in full
Cheapest paid plan Pro, $10 per seat per month billed annually ($18 monthly) Pro, $8.33 per user per month billed annually

If you want to try both before paying, Otter’s free plan lets you judge it on a few weeks of real meetings. Fireflies’ free plan let us judge one.

Fireflies or Otter: which should you pick?

  • You read the transcript, or your team has strong accents: Otter. Fewer word errors in both of our recordings. Visit Otter
  • You want the summary to hand out tasks: Fireflies. It caught the most decisions and named an owner for each action item; check the names. Visit Fireflies
  • You will not pay yet: Otter. Its free minutes cover several meetings a month; Fireflies’ did not cover our second one.
  • You want neither bot in the call: look at Granola in our five-tool test; it records on your Mac without joining the meeting.

How we tested

Both tools joined the same Google Meet call as bots while we played the recordings into it, on the same Mac, on the same day (15 November 2026), on free plans. Fireflies’ meeting transcript comes from a second run on 16 November on a new free account, because the first was hidden by the free-plan limit. We exported the transcripts and summaries unedited and scored them with the same script and checklist for every tool. Recordings: the AMI Meeting Corpus meeting ES2008a (CC BY 4.0, AMI Consortium / University of Edinburgh) and a scripted 2.5-minute weekly meeting read by a Lithuanian speaker of English. Full details and limits: methodology.

Think a number here is wrong, or a tool has changed since the test? Tell me and I will rerun it and publish what changes.

Sources